Reinsurance is delivering real innovation for mutuals and cooperatives say leading experts

Manchester, 11 May 2016: In advance of its 23rd biennial reinsurance conference the “MORO”, or the Meeting of Reinsurance Officials to give the event its full title, the International Cooperative and Mutual Insurance Federation (ICMIF) invited four eminent reinsurance leaders to kick off the discussion on key reinsurance issues in an exclusive round table for ICMIF’s Voice magazine. The MORO takes place in London from 6-8 June 2016.

Inga Beale, Chief Executive Officer, Lloyd’s of London, and keynote speaker at the ICMIF MORO this year, says that the (re)insurance industry as a whole is facing the innovation challenge. She explains that Lloyd’s has a specific focus on emerging risks and works with the market to look at what innovation and new products are required to address these risks. “The simple fact is,” Beale says “that, if reinsurers don’t come up with the products that business needs, then clients will look elsewhere.

Providers of new forms of capital are looking to be part of the reinsurance sector as they look for diversification in their asset portfolios, Beale says, and, in the current economic climate of low returns, are seeking yield. She goes on to say that the attraction so far has been for portfolios that are highly modelled with enormous amounts of data. For business that is more complex and requires more bespoke underwriting solutions, modelling is not giving the same amount of comfort as to assessment of exposures and expected profitability. Hence, Beale says, mutual and cooperative ICMIF member portfolios are likely to be attractive to reinsurers.

James Kent, President, Willis Re Inc., a previous MORO keynote speaker told Voice that both the new capital entering the market and traditional reinsurers are going through an unprecedented period of innovation.  “Examples include,” he says, “integrated reinsurance structures such as multi-line covers, new approaches to distribution with a greater involvement in direct insurance markets, and new capital structures such as the recently developed hybrid total return funds.”

Kent believes that traditional reinsurers still have the dominant share of the P&C reinsurance business largely as a result of established client relationships as well as their ability to support insurance companies across many different lines of business; but, he says, “any reinsurer (new or traditional) that does not seek new ways of doing business is likely to find themselves increasingly irrelevant to their customers.”

“Mutuals and cooperatives have traditionally aligned themselves with more traditional reinsurers,” says Kent, “but it is a good time to investigate the benefits of diversifying reinsurance partners even if clients ultimately retain their current trading partners.”

Kent says the world of risk is constantly evolving, and that mutuals/cooperatives, like all insurers, need to ensure they offer appropriate products and services if they are to remain relevant to their customers and members. “This may mean creating completely new insurance covers such as cyber liability, to respond to new exposures which previously simply didn’t exist,” he says. However, he also advises that cyber presents complex technical challenges in aspects such as coverage grants, pricing, loss prevention, managing accumulation and systemic risk.

“There are many emerging risks to think about,” warns Kent, “not just driverless cars and drones: what about nano-technology, e-cigarettes, genetically modified foods, trans-fats, social media abuse or slander, the list goes on. The important thing for mutuals/cooperatives and ICMIF members is to ensure their reinsurances are regularly reviewed for best practice.” 

Paula Jarzabkowski, Professor of Strategic Management at Cass Business School (London), also a former MORO keynote speaker, was asked how this alternative reinsurance capital could dramatically affect the traditional reinsurance market and whether the traditional market is in jeopardy.

In her reply Jarzabkowski said, “Securitized reinsurance capital has definitely increased competition in the traditional reinsurance market. In particular, it has taken market share and reduced pricing in catastrophe risk, which is where reinsurers predominantly subsidized their portfolios. At the same time, both collateralized reinsurance and catastrophe bonds are themselves in a more competitive phase, in which reducing cost is a key driver.” This, Jarzabkowski believes, has had some advantages for insurers generally, including mutuals and ICMIF members, because it has driven down the cost of both traditional reinsurance and securitized risk cover.

“Additionally,” Jarzabkowski says, “small and medium sized companies that primarily buy traditional rather than securitized reinsurance programmes remain attractive partners for traditional reinsurers. Hence, in some ways, ICMIF members are in a very strong position to find cost-effective risk cover, including larger ICMIF members having access to securitized reinsurance for specific parts of their risk cover.”

Lorie Graham, Senior Manager, Enterprise Risk Management and Insurance Services at ICMIF member organization American Agricultural Insurance Company (USA) was also consulted as part of this reinsurance roundtable discussion. Graham told Voice: “I do believe we are seeing true changes in the reinsurance industry. In the continued soft market, reinsurers are focused more than ever on risk management, capital management, risk appetite and emerging trends. By establishing risk appetite and optimizing capital levels, an organization can position itself for long-term success.”

Graham continues, “Traditional risk management techniques may not work for emerging risks. Likewise, it may not be cost-effective to allocate resources to unknown exposures. However, there are several methods a company can use to identify, evaluate, integrate and respond to emerging risks. Companies can build resilience into risk models surrounding strategy through diversification and response plans. Routine assessment of emerging risks can also provide a competitive advantage; by increasing preparedness an organization can detect new risks and adapt with agility.” 

For more information about the MORO visit:
Download the MORO reinsurance special edition of Voice magazine here.


Notes for editors overleaf with contact details and participant bios
Images can be supplied upon request –


Participants in the MORO reinsurance round table for Voice magazine were:

Inga Beale, Chief Executive Officer, Lloyd’s of London

Inga, the keynote speaker at the ICMIF MORO this year, joined Lloyd’s as the Chief Executive Officer in January 2014. Prior to Lloyd’s, Inga was the Group Chief Executive Officer at Canopius, a prominent Lloyd’s managing agent.

James Kent, President, Willis Re Inc.

James was appointed as President of Willis Re Inc (Willis Re North America) in 2010 and is also Co-President of Willis Re Global. James was one of the keynote speakers at the MORO in 2014. Willis Re is one of the main sponsors of the MORO 2016.

Lorie Graham, American Agricultural Insurance Company

Lorie champions the American Agricultural Insurance Company’s Enterprise Risk Management program. She has been in the insurance industry almost 30 years in various underwriting, risk management and research positions. She will share some of her insights during the forthcoming MORO in London.

Paula Jarzabkowski, Cass Business School, UK

Paula Jarzabkowski is a Professor of Strategic Management at Cass Business School in London. Her research focuses on strategy-as-practice in complex contexts, and her book Making a Market for Acts of God: The Practice of Risk-Trading in the Global Reinsurance Industry was recently published. Paula was a keynote speaker at the MORO in 2014.


For more information or to arrange interviews with ICMIF, please contact:

Liz Green, Senior Vice-President, Membership Services, ICMIF, +44 7793 264 220 or Alison Grant, Communications Manager, ICMIF +44 161 952 5078

About the mutual and cooperative insurance sector

  • The mutual sector holds 27% of global insurance market share by premium.
  • Premium growth of the insurance sector since 2007 is 30% vs 13.6% in industry
  • The sector’s assets of USD 8.3 trillion in 2014 have grown by 37% since 2007
  • Employment in the sector accounts for more than 1.1 million jobs
  • Over 955 million people are served as member/policyholders by mutual/cooperative insurers

About ICMIF (see and follow us on Twitter: @ICMIF_Web)

  • ICMIF holds eight years’ worth of exclusive data about the mutual sector
  • ICMIF delivers unique networking opportunities, market and member intelligence and external relations services. It takes a strong lead in encouraging best practice amongst its member firms in key insurance issues, including; performance management, legal and governance, marketing, brand and reputation, reinsurance and social and environmental performance.